Sometimes mapping actions to 30 different keys on a keyboard can be cumbersome since we only have a few free fingers whilst playing. The obvious solution is a controller, but which one is the best for silky smooth extended game sessions? This list is in no particular order, all of them are good choices depending on your taste and budget. If the cover photo gave you a fright, worry not, Kinect isn’t included.
DualShock 3
It has great functionality on PC(free third-party software needed to connect and map) and Mac (where it connects without the need of third-party software). If you grew up with PlayStation and got used to the stick layout, then look no further. For an average price you can get a controller that lasts with comfy triggers and buttons.
DS3 price: $35-40
DualShock 4
State-of-the-art with solid buttons and triggers. If you like the stick layout and have the money, then the DualShock 4 is for you. It feels more like playing with a DS3 with the same requirements to play on Windows. I personally tried both and I have to say I like the DS4 more because of the redesign to the historic DualShock form which makes it look like the ultimate piece of gaming hardware. It feels ever so slightly more comfortable in your hands when you play and has a glowing light that doesn’t serve a purpose but looks really cool.
DS4 price: $40-70 depending on which colour you get
Xbox 360 controller (wired or wireless with an adapter)
This controller is by far the cheapest in this list and the most supported one for Windows PC gaming, since, you know, it’s made by Microsoft and all. It’s sturdy, with good triggers but the D-pad feels a bit archaic and cheap. Still, you get the most out of a reasonably priced controller. If you don’t like the PlayStation analog stick layout and can’t be bothered with drivers and third-party software, get an Xbox 360 wired controller. Of course you can also buy the wireless version but know that you’ll have to purchase an additional wireless receiver in order to play.
X360 wired or wireless price: $25-30
Wireless receiver: $15-20
Xbox One controller
Very similar to the 360 controller but with an updated feel to it. The D-pad feels much nicer but personally, the triggers leave a lot to be desired. They feel almost toy-like, too soft and fragile. Additionally, the shoulder RB and LB buttons are cheap, clicky and reminiscent of the GameCube’s weird Z-button. Supported by almost all PC games nowadays and easy to install, it is the best choice for someone who likes the One controller and has the money for it. It is also available in some of the best colors I’ve seen in non-customized controllers.
Xbox One controller price: $35-60 depending on the color
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller
I’m as amazed as you are that this controller actually works on PC. I haven’t tried it myself but reports suggest that it works fine wirelessly using a free third-party driver but cannot be played while charging with the cable. Keep in mind that it doesn’t have analog triggers, which makes it undesirable for games that require variable trigger force actions, for example aiming in GTA IV (half-trigger vs full-trigger push) and the gas pedal in most racing games. It’s expensive but it’s durable and perfect if you have Shrek hands.
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller price: $70